Buying a mattress was quite a breeze when innerspring mattresses were the go-to models by default. But things have changed, and we now have more choices than ever before.
Well, having options is great. It allows you to customize your bed for a good sleep and enough rest, subsequently improving the quality of your life.
But there’s one HUGE PROBLEM. Mattresses literally come in thousands. And as any other mattress expert will tell you, whittling down your options to just one bed will be no easy task today.
The main reason for this is that modern mattresses are designed with specific users in mind. You could get a model that is engineered to curb your back and spinal pains.
On the same note, you’ll also find another mattress that has been thoughtfully tweaked to fit the bill for an adventurous and adrenaline-filled couple.
Basically, it boils down to your preferences with regard to the type of mattress (innerspring, memory foam, latex, and hybrid), thickness, and density.
You’ll also want to pay attention to each mattress’ behavior with regard to heat retention, motion isolation, noise, responsiveness, warmth, comfort, and durability.
As you can attest, buying a mattress today is fraught with anxiety more than any other home purchase. You’ll need to do lots of research and compare numerous models before landing a bed that offers the best value for your buck.
Not to fret though. We’ve done all the research and comparison so you won’t have to.
Our buying guide below whips everything that you need to know before hitting the market for a new mattress.
We’ve also searched and inquired from a few online retailers and found a list of 10 mattresses that previous buyers are stoked about. We bet there’s a great model for you here.
Keep your eyes open!
Best Mattress Buying Guide
Know the type of mattress…
I chose to begin with this type because it is by far the most common. If you’ve not shopped for a new mattress for decades, the chances are that an innerspring mattress is what you have in your bedroom.
True to their name, innerspring mattresses feature steel coils in their support system. But what makes them so popular?
One definite advantage that you get with innerspring mattresses is their low asking price.
While other mattress types soar in 1k-2k ballparks, most coil mattresses never go past the $500 mark. In fact, the market has several highly rated models that cost just slightly above a hundo.
So, if your budget doesn’t allow you to blow up over one grand on a new mattress, an innerspring might suffice.
Another advantage that these mattresses offer is their impressively bouncy support core. In fact, innerspring mattresses are rated the best on this front. This trait makes them the best beds for sex.
These mattresses also boast excellent air flow than other models. Thus, they might fit the bill if you are looking for a mattress that sleeps cool.
On the downside?
Innerspring mattresses suffer the most in almost all the vital aspects that make a good bed. For instance, they have poor contour ability compared to memory foam and latex models.
Therefore, they offer the least pressure point relief. Actually, I wouldn’t recommend an innerspring mattress if you are looking for a mattress that will alleviate your back and spinal pain or sciatica. These models will only aggravate your condition.
Innerspring mattresses also have poor motion isolation and can get annoyingly squeaky especially with nighttime activities.
They also offer the least resistance to dust mites and other allergens. Needless to mention, they are not the best for allergy sufferers.
Memory foam mattresses
Memory foam mattresses are the Lamborghini in this industry. For the uninitiated, memory foam was developed in 1966 for use by NASA.
This material was intended to hold astronaut in their seats and cushion them as they took off to space and during the re-entry into the atmosphere.
Memory foam is also known as viscoelastic foam. This name emanates from its ability to react to your body temperature and contour to your natural shape. It also regains its original shape after you’ve woken up which is a guarantee of durability.
What makes memory foam popular?
- It molds to your shape for excellent pressure relief and joint pain alleviation
- Memory foam holds and supports your spine in its natural alignment
- It accommodates different sleeping styles
- Has inherent hypoallergenic traits
- Has good durability
What are its drawbacks?
This is the major issue that plagues memory foam mattresses. This problem, however, varies with the density and thickness of the mattress. Thicker and high-density models tend to trap less heat than their low-density alternatives.
Memory foam is made from a blend of polyurethane and other chemicals. Therefore, they are the worst culprits with regard to off-gassing.
Latex is derived from the sap of rubber trees. These mattresses are becoming increasingly popular especially because of their minimal off-gassing issues.
Most chiropractors and osteopaths also recommend these models due to their unique blend of soft comfort and support.
Latex comes in 2 types; Dunlop and Talalay. The former is known to be a little bit eco-friendlier in that it uses fewer chemicals in its extraction.
It’s also known to be a bit firmer and thus makes a superb choice if you want a mattress with optimum back support.
On the other hand, Talalay latex uses more chemicals but it’s also softer than Dunlop. That being said, it makes a great purchase if you want something softer yet supportive for your bad back.
The major drawback with latex mattresses is their high price tags. These mattresses are also made to order and might, therefore, take some time before they are shipped to your door.
As the name alludes, these mattresses offer the best of several worlds. Common hybrid mattresses combine an innerspring coil system with either latex or memory foam. Comfortaire, a US-based brand, however, is unique for using latex and memory foam pads on airbeds.
All in all, the various materials used in hybrid mattresses complement each other to offer you an all-round bed solution. For instance, a hybrid mattress featuring a coil system and memory foam offers excellent contour ability and bounciness- a feature that memory foam mattresses lack.
Thickness and Density
It is forgivable to think that these 2 aspects refer to the same thing but they don’t. So, let’s dissect them separately for clarity.
Thickness is just that; the size of the mattress; how thin or thick it is. Have you ever wondered why some mattresses max out at 20 inches thick while others are only 6 inches in height? What matters in terms of thickness?
First, thicker mattresses and toppers tend to offer more support than their thin alternatives. That being said, a heavier person will want to go with a thicker mattress. Vice versa is true.
Second, thick mattresses combined with high density tend to ‘float’ you in the air, subsequently minimizing heat retention to allow you a cool sleep.
The ideal thickness of the mattress also depends on your sleeping style. For instance, side snoozers tend to bottom out thin mattresses easily with their shoulders and hip joint. If you fall into this category, you really want to avoid thin mattresses. A mattress with 6-8 inches thickness seems ideal for you.
Back dreamers, on the other hand, want lots of support around their buttocks and upper back. If you love memory foam mattresses, a model with around 6-8 inches will suffice. For latex lovers, go for a mattress that is around 6 inches.
If you want to enjoy the bouncy characteristic of memory foam-innerspring mattress, consider a bed that features a 4-inch memory foam topper.
Simply put, density refers to the amount of material (foam or latex) that a mattress uses per cubic foot. For instance, if you have a memory foam mattress that claims to have a density of 5lbs per cubic foot, then a one-cubic-foot block of the mattress will weigh approximately 5 pounds.
Mattresses come in 3 density levels
Low density (3lbs and under)
These mattresses feel soft right off the bat because they tend to melt down to your body heat faster. As such, they are ideal for people who prefer a soft bed.
The drawback with low-density mattresses is that they offer the least support. Thus, they may not be the best especially for heavy persons or if you have a history of back and spinal pains.
Medium density (4-5lbs)
This is the most popular bracket with most sleepers. The thing with these mattresses is that they combine a good amount of firmness and softness.
Medium density mattresses don’t feel stiff to your skin like high-density mattresses. On the other hand, you won’t hit the bottom easily as it’s the case with low-density models.
High Density (6+ pounds)
Mattresses with this density are the best if your doctor has recommended a firm mattress for your back. These mattresses feel stiff at first. But they melt down to your body heat after some time to mold around you.
High-density mattresses are also the best for heavier-than-average sleepers (over 250lbs).
These mattresses don’t sag or form a crater easily compared to other medium and low-density mattresses. What this means is that high-density mattresses are the most durable. They will also cost you top dollar though.
Other key considerations
- Check out the trial period– reliable models offer you up to a 100-day window to try out a mattress and return it if it does not meet your needs.
- Consider the warranty– regardless of how much the mattress cost, go for a brand that offers a good warranty. There’s always something fishy about a manufacturer that won’t stand by its products
- Read previous buyers’ reviews and feedback– previous owners’ reviews are of paramount importance on your online purchase journey.
Well, not all of them will be authentic. However, a pro or con that comes up in most feedbacks is likely to be true.
- Go for certified mattresses– if you are worried about subjecting yourself or your family to harmful chemicals, consider whether the mattress has been certified.Common mattress certifications include CertiPur-US, GOLS (Global Organic Latex Standard), GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standard), and OEKO-TEX.
Top 10 Best Mattresses Reviews
At this juncture, let’s bring you our picks of the best mattresses for 2018. For those in a hurry, our quick-second comparison table below captures the major highlights that differentiate these models.
We’ve also ranked the mattresses accordingly from the best performer with regard to comfort, support, and durability to the least.
|1||Classic Brands Cool Gel||Memory Foam (with gel)||12||medium||25|
|2||Casper Mattress||Memory foam||10||(zoned) Medium and Firm||10|
|4||Linenspa Mattrress||Hybrid (innerspring and latex)||10||Medium||10|
|6||Signature Sleep Memoir||Memory Foam||12||Firm||1|
|7||Pure Green||Latex||9||Medium firm||10|
|8||Live and Sleep||Memory foam||10||Medium Firm||20|
|9||Oliver Smith||Hybrid (Innerspring and memory foam)||12||Medium firm||5|
|10||Swiss Ortho Sleep||Memory foam with gel||13||Firm||10|
Classic Brands Cool Gel Memory Foam (12’’)
Our best recommendation here is a memory foam mattress that has received lots of praise from a wide array of people. The Classic Brands features a medium-plush feel and 12-inch thickness.
These 2 attributes make it a suitable choice for lightweight to average weight sleepers. Its medium-density feel means that it melts and contours to your body curves and relieves pressure points while still being supportive.
This might be a good bet if you are looking for a mattress that won’t cause back pains. In fact, most people love it for this.
Worth noting, the Classic Brands features 2 layers of cooling gel. Although several people note that it still sleeps hot in hot weather, several others report that they sleep slightly cooler on it.
- Smell dissipates fast
- Medium-plush relieves back pain
- Soft yet supportive enough
- Sleeps slightly hotter
The Casper Mattress
The Casper mattress is another highly rated model that you’ll certainly want to try out. Casper says that this mattress is currently being used by over a million sleepers and still counting.
But what’s the reason behind its popularity?
What we like most about it is the new and improved construction design. It features 4 layers that have been thoughtfully stacked to offer optimal support where your body needs it most.
The first layer is a comfort layer that has a latex-like feel with immediate springiness and excellent cooling features to offer you a cool sleeping surface. This layer is followed by a memory foam layer that contours to your body to aid in pressure relief.
Next is a zoned support layer where the magic happens. This layer is actually made up of 2 distinct foams; a softer one located along the ends and a firmer layer at the middle for your hips.
Casper says that the essence of this is to offer more support where you need it while supporting your neck, shoulders, spine, and hips in a neutral alignment. The last layer is a heavy-duty polyfoam that gives the mattress its shape.
Importantly, this mattress is Certipur-us certified and comes with a 100-night trial period and 10 years of rock-solid warranty.
- Zoned support is a thoughtful yet effective design
- Accommodates all sleepers
- Certipur-us certified for your safety
- Its chemical smell may take some time to dissipate completely
- Some find it too soft
Leesa Memory Foam Mattress
This mattress is for those who love sleeping in a super soft yet supportive blend. While I often recommend such a mattress to lightweight and medium-weight sleepers, the Leesa could offer a good sleep to heavy persons as well.
It features a 2-inch medium density memory foam that offers all the attributes known to this material without the sinking sensation. This top layer cradles you to relief your sore muscles and pressure points
- Unique blend of construction materials
- Minimal heat build-up
- Minimal smell
- Could be little bit firm for people with bad backs
Linenspa Latex Hybrid Mattress (10-inch)
Are you looking for a mattress that offers an incredible memory foam alternative without the feel of sinking into the mattress? Check this one out.
This model from Linenspa features several layers of foam and latex on an innerspring base. The latex topper has a slightly firmer feel and gets a boost in terms of response from the coils.
These 2 components work together to make this mattress a good bet for heavy people and those with back pains that require a firm mattress.
Worth noting, latex sleeps cooler than memory foam. This coupled with the innerspring system also renders it nicely as a great pick for people who sleep hot at night.
- Individually wrapped coils for motion isolation
- Latex is firm and supportive to aching backs
- It sleeps cool
- Might feel so stiff at first
Signature Sleep Contour
Some people just love innerspring mattresses not only for their bounciness that helps in creating rhythm during sex. But also because they are relatively affordable and are not chemically set.
What we have here is one of the most highly rated innerspring mattresses around the web today. It costs way below the $150 mark and features 15-gauge coils that give it a soft yet supportive feel.
This mattress might be a good choice for a couple and kids too. Generally, we don’t recommend these beds for seniors since they tend to make getting out of the bed quite hard.
What we like most about it is that each coil has been individually pocketed. This minimizes motion disturbance especially if your partner moves a lot at night.
To ensure that the springs don’t poke your back, the Signature Sleep Contour also has a 1.6-inch layer of foam. It boosts comfort and curbs motion transfer even further.
We also like that it is reversible. This prolongs the lifetime of the mattress thereby giving you a quality bang for each buck spent.
- It’s reversible
- Comfortable and supportive
- Some find it quite softer than expected
Signature Sleep Memoir Memory Foam Mattress (12 Inch)
The Signature Sleep Memoir is a certipur-US certified memory foam mattress. This is a guarantee that it has been made in the USA and does not contain chemicals that might put your health in jeopardy.
Right off the bat, this is a high-density model with a firm feel. This might suffice if a medium-density mattress causes or escalates your back pains. It’s also a good bet for weighty sleepers who might bottom out a less-dense mattress.
Furthermore, its high-density renders it nicely as a good mattress for sex since you won’t be sinking too deep into the mattress.
Does it reek odors?
Well, similar to other mattresses of its type, the Signature Sleep Memoir will let out some odors after unpacking it. However, most buyers affirm that it is not annoying and it dissipates fast.
- Uses eco-friendly materials
- Super comfortable
- Smell dissipates fast
- Has no advanced cooling technologies (may sleep hot)
Pure Green Natural Latex Mattress
What are you looking for, a durable mattress that you won’t have to replace after only one year? Are you looking for a hypoallergenic mattress for your allergic condition? Do you need a mattress that is both comfy and supportive?
Perhaps the Pure Green Latex is what you have in mind.
This mattress uses natural latex (this explains its high price tag) and has a medium-plush design. It might fill the slot for side and back sleepers and arthritic people who want constant support.
It also makes a good purchase for people who are super sensitive to petroleum odors that memory foam mattresses emanate.
When you buy the Pure Green mattress, you’ll also be benefiting from a super soft cover made from organic cotton and New Zealand wool for a more breathable and cooling sleeping surface.
- Natural latex is inherently hypoallergenic
- Soft and highly breathable mattress and cover
- It’s non toxic
- One buyer reports a weird smell
Live and Sleep – Resort Sleep Classic
The 4.5/5-star rating that this mattress has garnered from its close to 2k verified purchasers speaks volumes about its ability to improve your sleep and life.
This is a medium-density memory foam model with a cloud-like feel and excellent conformability. Thus, it makes a good option for side and stomach sleepers who are after a mattress with orthopedic properties.
We also appreciate that the cooling innovation that this manufacturer has used in its construction. Scanning through the reviews, very few people reported that it slept hot.
This excellent airflow plus the motion isolation attribute of memory foam thereby makes this mattress a great option for light sleepers who are startled by the least movements by their partners and heat.
Other great features here include a removable soft fabric cover and certipur-us and OEKO-TEX certifications.
- Sleeps cool
- Price is a steal
- Certipur-us and Oeko-tex certified for safety
- A few reports of mattresses that didn’t inflate completely
Oliver Smith 12-inch Hybrid Mattress
Memory foam and innerspring systems have always been good together. When used together, these 2 materials have been time tested and found to be effective in offering comfort and pressure relief without the mattress being overly expensive for the average homeowner.
But Oliver Smith takes this goodness to a new level by throwing a pure organic cover into the mix to boost breathability. This mattress might, therefore, be your go-to model if you toss and turn a lot due to heat.
The Oliver Smith mattress uses independently pocketed 15-gauge coils and most of the odors have been removed from the factory.
Most people report that it ships with virtually no smell although airing it out might still be necessary. Worth noting is that it comes in all sizes; twin, full, queen, king, and California king.
- Has minimal to zero smells
- It’s super comfortable
- It’s highly breathable
- Has poor edge support
Swiss Ortho Sleep
This mattress might be your solution if you are looking for a mattress that has been specifically designed to curb back pains.
The Swiss Ortho features several layers of foam that oozes comfort and support whether you are a side snoozer or a back dreamer.
One thing that you might appreciate is that it does not give in to the bottom (I’m looking at you, heavy-weight sleepers).
The most standout feature here is the 2-inch gel layer that has been incorporated into its design. This layer promotes even distribution of your weight across the sleeping surface for optimum relaxation.
It also dissipates your body heat away from you for as long as possible to offer you a good sleep without heating issues.
As if that’s not enough, the Swiss Ortho also features a removable and machine-washable white bamboo cover. This cover not only contributes to your bed’s hygiene levels, but it’s also known to be inherently hypoallergenic.
Worth noting, however, is that this mattress has high-density feel. You might, therefore, find it quite firm if you prefer cloud-like mattresses. Lightweight users could also take some time to get used to it.
- Gel layer helps minimize heating issues
- Great value for money
- Has minimal motion transfer for a restful sleep
- Lightweight sleepers may find it quite firm
Sleep is subjective. A mattress that works great for your back might be hellish to another one. So, of most importance, go for a mattress that portrays all the attributes that you’d want for your bed. As I told you before, pay close attention to firmness and softness levels and support.
In addition, remember that buying a mattress in a box is quite tricky since you won’t have the opportunity to try it out first. So, to alleviate any inconveniences, check the label on the box to ensure that you are getting exactly what you paid for before signing the delivery note.
So, what next?
We hope that you’ve found a great model for your sleep from our top 10 best picks. We at sleepify would also love to hear from you.
Do you have any unanswered questions about mattresses? Have you recently invested in a mattress that you think that it’s not paying back for itself as it should? Is there a mattress that you would like us to review here?
Please engage us in the comments section and we’ll promptly help you out.